Amy McNeill · VP of Field Marketing · Aug 15, 2026
| Layer | Today (91 Gen4 only) | 12-mo cost | Proposed (248 all) | Year 1 cost | Δ vs today |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reputation | Swell · $119.78 × 91 | $130,800 | Promo Republic · $16 × 248 (Gen4 Jan 27 →) | $41,792 | −$89K |
| Social | Promo Social · $17 × 91 | $18,564 | Promo Republic · $17 × 248 | $50,592 | +$32K (157 new) |
| Listings | Yext/Yelp · $23.87 × 91 | $26,066 | Promo Republic · $20 × 248 (Gen4 Jun 27 →) | $43,140 | +$17K (157 new) |
| CRM | GHL Base + 27 practices (agency $150 elsewhere) | $14,888 | GHL Base + 248 practices | $20,868 | +$6K (221 new) |
| Website / SEO | MSP · $173.33 × 75 (Gen4) | $156,000 | MSP wind-down · retires Feb 27 | $65,000 | −$91K Yr1 −$156K/yr Yr2+ |
| Portfolio total | $346,318 | All 248 locations · one integrated stack | $278,562 | −$68K | |
Worse before better: Sep–Dec 26 runs ~$37K/mo (Gen4 double-billing on Swell + Yext + MSP while SGA/MODIS onboards Promo Republic). Feb 27 = the cliff: MSP retires, monthly drops 60%. Steady state Jun 27+: $14.8K/mo = $178K/yr. Window: Sep 2026 → Aug 2027. Source: vendor-pricing-matrix-2026-08-04-v5-DM_EDITS.xlsx
Conservative — Promo Republic value only counts the 157 SGA/MODIS practices getting these tools for the first time (Gen4 91 already has Swell/Yext/Promo Social). GHL NP-value formula uses 221 new locations (excludes the 27 already live) at just 1 additional NP/mo — a ~0.15% lift on a 400-800/yr NP baseline. MSP Yr1 captures 5 months of the $13K/mo savings ($156K/yr Yr2+).
| Category | Priority 1 | Who resolves |
|---|---|---|
| NAP (name/address/phone/hours/website) | 63 | Promo Republic |
| Description (present, length, city, CTA) | 40 | Promo Republic |
| Photos (volume + quality) | 6 | Promo Social |
| Category (dental-relevant + secondary) | 2 | Promo Republic |
| Appointment (Reserve w/ Google, booking, scheduler) | 338 | Neurality (separate track) |
| Promo Republic addressable · Priority 1 | 111 | + 415 MANUAL findings collapse when PR becomes source of truth |
72 non-West practices are D or F. By contrast, SGA West audited (74 practices, already has Swell/Yext/Promo Social) has median score 91 · zero F's · only 7 D-or-F. SGA West with the tools = our A-average control group. The proof these tools work is inside our own network.
Source: docs/audits/gbp-audit rollup 2026-07-22 · filtered to Business Unit ≠ SGA West via Master Crosswalk API · 156 of the 157 non-West practices audited (deterministic GMB-only, May-Jul 2026). SGA West control group (74 audited): median score 91 · zero F's · 7 D-or-F.
| # | Decision | Type | $ / commitment | Owner if approved |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Promo Republic (4 layers) + GHL rollout across 248 Phased on Swell (Dec 26) + Yext (May 27) sunsets · MSP retires Feb 27 · GHL starts Nov 2026 |
ASK | $278K · Sep 26–Aug 27 → $178K/yr steady state · $68K less than today across 2.7× the locations |
Amy · Dakota · Growth Managers |
| 2 | Commercial term posture — 24-month vs 12-month on Promo Republic Roxy: 24-month locks in current pricing + better service economics (Listings cleanup, onboarding, ongoing support) + phased rollout flexibility · 12-month = +7% price premium |
ASK | Recommend 24-mo Saves ~$9.5K Yr1 · ~$11K/yr steady · ~$22K over the term |
Amy · Roxy (Reputation.com) |
| 3 | Sept 5 Patient Funnel scorecard launch 20 Focus Practices → network-wide by end of Q4 |
Endorsement | No new $ | Amy · Dakota · Scott |
| 4 | Helpdesk ecosystem model Intake → sga3p → Web Dev / Studio / Growth Manager routing · SSO-gated intranet |
Endorsement | No new $ | Amy · Growth Managers |
Amy McNeill · VP of Field Marketing · amcneill@gen4dental.com
Source: vendor-pricing-matrix-2026-08-04-v5-DM_EDITS.xlsx · Companion decks: sga-growth.dev/reports/patient-funnel-project/